Wednesday, January 4, 2012

How does the poem "The White Man's Burden" relate to British imperialism in India?

"The White Man's Burden" is a poem by Rudyard Kipling published in 1899. British imperialism around the world, including India, was already in full swing by then, so we can't say that Kipling caused British imperialism.

But if you read the poem, there's something very jarring about it, at least to a modern cosmopolitan reader: It is unabashedly, even proudly, racist and imperialist. It was written in response to the US invasion of the Philippines, and the story it tells is not of a powerful country conquering and oppressing a weak one, but of a superior, advanced culture trying their very best to civilize and improve an inferior, primitive one, and being constantly thwarted by the primitive savages. It isn't exactly rejoicing in imperialism, but the downsides it talks about are all about how hard it is being the White imperialist, constantly misjudged for his altruistic actions. The desires of the people being conquered are conveniently ignored.

Thus, we can think of "The White Man's Burden" as a kind of apologia for imperialism, and particularly focused at American and British readers. That word is sometimes translated "apology", but "apology" sounds like you're saying sorry for something you agree is bad; an apologia is a defense of why it is not bad, even though so many people seem to think so. We can't really know what Kipling himself believed (perhaps it was intended as satire?), but if the poem is read literally, it is a staunch defense of imperialism as the necessary burden of White men to bring civilization to the primitive masses, whether they want it or not.

This was of course a narrative that the British used heavily, in an attempt to justify their imperialism in India, Africa, and around the world. "It's for their own good" makes the violence and exploitation much easier to swallow than it would have been if they'd admitted it was mainly for the gain of the rich and powerful in Britain. And they had just enough examples of actual improvements in standard of living (accomplished in the most violent way possible, of course) to back up their argument; yes, there was in fact real economic development in India under the British Raj. Defenders of imperialism conveniently ignored of course that there could have been much more development had they engaged in fair and equal trade rather than imperialist exploitation---but there was in fact some development, which gave them some measure of excuse or deniability, and many in Britain clung to these excuses and spread them widely. Kipling's poem is part of that attempt to give an ethical and altruistic veneer to a project that was at its core violent and exploitative.

This soon backfired, however, as "the White Man's Burden" actually became a satirical slogan against imperialism in the US and Britain (and is sometimes still used that way today). It was used as an example of how weak and inhumane the justifications for imperialism truly were.

Monday, January 2, 2012

Why was the police response to the Columbine shooting criticized? Was the IMS used? If so, what amount of success did it have? If not, why not?...

In 1999, when Columbine occurred, school shootings were relatively rare. According to Slate magazine (Cullen 2009), there were 37 school shootings in America between 1974 and 2000. While this may seem like a lot (over one per year), it is a very small number compared to the number of shootings since Columbine. As a result, law enforcement agencies were not well-prepared for such an incident. The law enforcement agencies in Littleton were ultimately criticized for being too slow to respond to Columbine, causing unnecessary loss of life.


There were two major failures in the response to Columbine. The first was that response teams were more trained to handle hostage crises than active shooters. As a result, their standard operating procedure was to surround the building, create perimeters, and then take steps to free the hostages inside. Less-trained forces, such as city police, were also typically instructed to wait for better-equipped, more highly-resourced, and highly-trained agencies to come on the scene rather than acting independently. Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold did not hold hostages; rather, they gunned down people inside the building. As a result, typical hostage-management techniques failed, and far too much time was taken up by using these traditional methods. 


The second major failure at Columbine was the lack of a systematic, well-run incident management system (IMS). While Mell and Sztajnkrycer (2004) noted there was an Incident Command System (ICS) in place and praised the successes of said system, they also noted several flaws. First, there had been few interagency training opportunities, which meant most of the individual responders had not been trained to work with other agencies. This led to issues; for example, one team not understanding another team's language, or confusion as to who had higher authority. Technology also became a problem, as the different agencies had different methods of communicating and used different radio frequencies. Finally, the lack of smooth interagency communication led to many mistakes, including an overrun of surplus volunteers that created many logistical and media challenges.


Unfortunately, there have been many school shootings since Columbine, and law enforcement has much more training now. If a shooting were to happen today, two important steps would be


1) Whoever is first on the scene takes control of the situation, including assessing if there is an active shooter.


2) If there is an active shooter, officers now follow the "active shooter protocol," in which teams of four officers enter the building as soon as possible in a wedge formation. The primary goal of these officers is to take down the shooter as quickly as possible. 


Additional improvements in technology and joint/ interagency training have also allowed law enforcement and emergency response to make great gains in containing shooting situations. A well-run, well-trained Incident Command System/ Incident Management System, with a clear chain of command, is critical in these situations.

Do you think that the poet is clever in taking the other road? Why?

Cleverness can be defined as innovation, which means doing something people have not done before you.  In that case, the poet has done something clever when he took a road no one else had, or that few people had.  It may not be that no one has taken the road, but just that fewer people have.



Then took the other, as just as fair,


And having perhaps the better claim,


Because it was grassy and wanted wear;


Though as for that the passing there


Had worn them really about the same … 



To extend the metaphor, because this is what the poem is really about, it is brave to take risks, and can also be interpreted as clever.  It depends on what you do once you take the road.  Just the act of taking the road is not much. It is an initial choice to do something different.  It is what you do that is different that matters. 


We can interpret the speaker’s words in the last stanza of the poem to mean that when he took this less-traveled road and did something different from everyone else, he was happy with his choice. 



I shall be telling this with a sigh


Somewhere ages and ages hence:


Two roads diverged in a wood, and I—


I took the one less traveled by,


And that has made all the difference. 



Of course “all the difference” is open to interpretation.  I guess if you are a pessimist you could say that it could be a bad difference instead of a good difference.  However, given the context of the poem it seems like the speaker took a different road and is happy with his choice, so it was a good difference for him.  Whatever decision he made and innovation he decided on, it worked out and he had a successful and happy life after all of it.

How does the family obligation to get married affect the Bennet sisters in Pride and Prejudice? What effect does this have on them as characters,...

Jane Bennet feels the pressure most strongly.  As the eldest daughter, and -- as her mother tells her often -- the most beautiful, her chances of making a good match are probably the best.  When Mr. Bingley finally proposes to her, she tells Elizabeth that she must go "'instantly'" to her mother, and she is most happy about the fact that "'what [she] has to relate [to Mrs. Bennet] will give such pleasure to all [her] dear family.'"  She knows that her mother will be thrilled about her engagement and that her marriage to Bingley will mean that her mother and sisters always have somewhere to go after Mr. Bennet's death.  Jane is so elated that she wonders "'how [she] shall [...] bear so much happiness."  Her relief and elation over the fact that she will marry well indicates the extent to which she's internalized and been affected by the pressure put on the girls to find rich husbands. 


As far as the other sisters, Kitty and Lydia have "minds [that] were more vacant than their sisters'," and the pressure for at least one of the Bennet girls to marry well really doesn't seem to have any effect on them.  They are more interested in flirting and balls than serious engagements and would be happier with the attentions of a handsome officer than the affections of an unattractive gentleman.  The fact that Lydia willfully elopes with George Wickham, a poor soldier, proves this.  Nor is Mary particularly affected by a sense of family obligation in marriage.  In fact, Mary seems to have no interest in men or marriage whatsoever, and because she is plain, there is little expectation that she will be the one to save the family. 


Elizabeth is also relatively unaffected by the pressure on the girls to marry well.  She cannot bring herself to value wealth over love and respect, as is clear from her initial rejection of Mr. Darcy's marriage proposals, proposals which she can only accept in the end, after she has developed both love and respect for the gentleman.  Her rejection of Mr. Collins's proposal, despite the fact that he will inherit Longbourn when Mr. Bennet dies is further proof of this.  Elizabeth even tells him, "'To fortune, I am perfectly indifferent [...].'"  Her mother obviously puts a great deal of pressure on her to accept this proposal, refusing to speak to Elizabeth ever again if she persists in rejecting Mr. Collins, but it does no good. 


Thus, Jane is really the only daughter who feels the pressure keenly.  She certainly doesn't marry Bingley because he's rich and can help her family, but her relief that she has fallen in love with a rich man is apparent.  Though Charlotte Lucas advises Jane (via Elizabeth), early on, to be more forward with her affections in order to secure Bingley's, pressure to marry well never does compel Jane to act in a manner that her conscience couldn't support.  Therefore, she does feel the pressure most deeply, but she has too much integrity to allow it to dictate her actions.

What are the similarities between academic and nonacademic texts?

It is much easier to say what academic and nonacademic texts do not have in common rather than their similarities, but I can say the following:


Both academic and nonacademic texts may be written with the goal to persuade, to entertain, or to inform. They differ in their approach to these goals, though, with academic texts relying far more on research and factual, verifiable material for their content. Nonacademic texts may also include research or verifiable material, but are less likely to include references to any source material, and may be published in a rather informal setting.


Academic and nonacademic texts are also typically written for a particular audience. While nonacademic texts are intended more for mass, public consumption than scholarly or academic texts, they may be targeted towards special interests or occupations in society. 


When it comes to format, both academic and nonacademic texts may be found in print, periodical, and digital forms. 

The culture of the Plains Indians was changed by _____?

The best answer to this question would have to be "the horse."  Introduced by Spaniards in the sixteenth century, the horse revolutionized Plains life.  Before the horse, Native Americans used dogs to drag their belongings.  The horse allowed greater mobility, thus allowing Plains tribes to follow the buffalo.  Horses were also considered symbols of wealth, especially among tribes such as the Lakota and Cheyenne.  It would not be uncommon for a chief to boast herds of over one hundred horses.  Horses were also the targets of raids.  Native Americans also used the horse in warfare as well.  The horse allowed tribes such as the Blackfoot and Crow to rule large swaths of territory.  Learning to ride a horse was a rite of passage in all young natives' lives, especially among boys who were needed as warriors and hunters for a tribe.  

Sunday, January 1, 2012

What literacy device is the author using to convey the following point of view? "In both countries it was clearer than crystal to the lords of the...

The above quote is from the first chapter of A Tale of Two Cities, and it is what we call an allusion.


An allusion is a literary device which references ideas or people with political, religious, social, or literary significance. In the above, the quote is an allusion to Christ's two miracles of the loaves and fishes in the New Testament. The first miracle involved Christ feeding five thousand people by multiplying five loaves of bread and two fishes. The second miracle involved Christ multiplying seven loaves and a few fishes to feed four thousand who had gathered to hear him.


In the above quote, the French and English aristocracy were the "lords of the State preserves." They were the ones responsible for the general welfare of the people; yet, the irony is that they lived their lives oblivious to the true nature of the average citizen's struggles. While they presided over plenty, a majority of the populace in both countries lived subsistence lives. Basically, the aristocratic classes enjoyed lavish lifestyles and concluded that "things in general were settled for ever."


Additionally, many aristocrats had access to game preserves that average French and English citizens were forbidden to enter. In these preserves, the wealthy and the powerful indulged their love for game sport. The meat was not used to feed the hungry masses (hence the irony of the allusion to Christ's miracles), but to tease the palates of those who were already accustomed to good food on a daily basis. It was said that the English and French monarchy "trod with stir enough, and carried their divine rights with a high hand." In other words, the aristocrats acted like gods but failed to fulfill their responsibilities to their people.

find square roots of -1+2i

We have to find the square root of `-1+2i` i.e. `\sqrt{-1+2i}` We will find the square roots of the complex number of the form x+yi , where ...